The secret dinner where Labour grandees met to plot Brexit reversal

The secret dinner where Labour grandees met to plot Brexit reversal

What happens next on Britain’s relationship with the European Union is a question “for another day” Andy Burnham said on Friday. It may already be too late for that. The i Paper can reveal Labour grandees met this week for private talks to discuss what getting closer to the EU might look like. Among the attendees were former Chancellor Rachel Reeves, who has already publicly argued that Britain’s future should be in the bloc. Meanwhile, former deputy prime minister David Lammy became the latest big beast to tell Burnham he should take Labour into the next general election with a pledge to negotiate rejoining the EU and put the resulting deal to a public referendum. But having secured long-awaited deals on food and drink, youth visas, carbon emissions and assurances that Britain’s industries will not be cut off by the Made in Europe scheme, Burnham will want to take stock of Friday’s summit before considering his next steps. “We will not be running ahead of public opinion” the PM insisted. The trouble is the thorny Brexit debate, like nature, abhors a vacuum. Private dinner of Labour big beasts On the pro-Europe side, what that debate looks like is currently up for grabs. A group of Labour heavyweights met privately on Wednesday to discuss the situation. Sir Keir Starmer’s former director of communications Tim Allan played host to Reeves and former Business Secretary Peter Kyle. Nick Thomas-Symonds, who had led on UK reset negotiations before being replaced in Burnham’s reshuffle attended, alongside former Treasury minister Spencer Livermore.Representatives of the current government and think tankers dined on tuna and chicken at the north London gathering. Also in attendance was Starmer biographer Tom Baldwin, a Labour adviser who was communications director for the People’s Vote campaign—which pushed for a second referendum on Brexit. “It was just friends catching up,” insisted one attendee. Another said the dinner was arranged months ago. Nevertheless, the meeting shows how the two sides are squaring up, with the pro-Europeans not content to let the Brexiteers, and newly formed ‘Stay Out’ campaign, own the debate. “We need to be better this time around. We can’t have a return to the blue bloody berets,” one pro-rejoin dinner attendee said, referring to the 2019 marches in favour of a second referendum organised by the People’s Vote movement. “We can’t have the same people making the same arguments as ten years ago,” a second attendee told The i Paper. “I don’t think anyone is saying Brexit has worked financially for the country. But secondly, Europe has changed. Both the invasion of Ukraine and the American withdrawal of huge amounts of money for defence are new arguments. What you can’t have is the same faces and same arguments as 2016.” Brexiteers get a head start There is some concern Burnham has given his opponents a head start. The campaign to ‘Stay Out’ has already kicked off. That’s chaired by Oliver Lewis, who also worked for Vote Leave, and acted as deputy chief negotiator for the UK in trade negotiations with the bloc. A decade on from the referendum and even without a Brexit bus, it’s déjà vu all over again. Lewis is already claiming rejoining the EU would cost Britain £750m a week in contributions. The figure excludes money returned to Britain through grants and other economic benefits. It’s had the obvious effect of winding up his political opponents. “People are already talking about their new number of £750m even if it’s a made-up number that’s only fit for the side of a bus. Whereas on our side, it appears people are only commissioning polls to make themselves feel better,” one pro-European Westminster source said. The PM’s allies say his aim is to start a conversation on a future relationship with the bloc that could lead to him making a pitch to voters in the next general election. Burnham himself has said he might go as far as pledging to rejoin the EU but as yet has no conclusive position. Another pro-rejoin figure involved in the discussions said that without a settled agreement on the option the Prime Minister wants to go for, “the goverment is not wanting to put a team in place to do the kind of campaigning and argumentative work that they don’t want to.” They said: “I think that there is a real question mark about who’s going to lead, and who’s going to do the hard work in terms of rebuttal and discussion.” Meanwhile, a former Cabinet minister said: “We don’t want to repeat the same mistakes as before, of every aspect of the debate being untethered by fact.” An opposing argument is that Burnham is perfectly well able to make his own case for a closer relationship with Europe with no external campaign group. “If people don’t want to rejoin, we won’t rejoin,” an ally of the prime minister said. “That’s why he’s not immediately gone to specific options, but I can’t imagine he’s just going to stand back and let all the people have that conversation about Europe without him.” “I am leading on Europe,” Burnham insisted to MPs on Wednesday. But how far and how fast that leadership extends is a question troubling the fledgling rejoin campaign. One pro-EU former Cabinet minister said it was “completely understandable” that Burnham would want to see “how the land lies” following Friday’s Brexit reset summit before settling on a position. “He’s also now gone through the actual lived experience of negotiating with EU, which is not easy,” they said. Burnham’s next intervention Burnham will probably intervene again on Europe around the time he releases his largely domestic 10-year plan, which is expected in mid-December. Officials are still deciding whether the options for Europe form part of the plan or remain as a separate document, speech or op-ed from the prime minister. The slowdown comes amid hesitation from Cabinet members, opposition from Labour MPs in Brexit-backing constituencies, and warnings from continental diplomats that long-term talks could not advance until the UK establishes an overarching strategy On Friday, Burnham said a possible “informal brainstorming” on the future relationship might take place with the EU. But some want him to hurry up. One pro-European predicted there would be an “empty void” until Burnham picks his position. “A generous interpretation is that Andy might as well start the conversation now,” one waspish Labour MP said. “The ungenerous view is that they don’t know where they are going.” Another former Cabinet minister said: “The issue that No 10 is going to have over the next six or seven months is what they actually want to get to at the end of this and not allowing it to go completely out of their control. “There is also a range of other things you can do here. You can rejoin the customs union. There’s lots of things you can do, but my worry is unless No 10 gets control, you are going to end up with Rejoin versus Stay.” The suggestion Burnham is hesitating is wide of the mark, argue his allies. They say he has been concentrating on making the Brussels summit a success. Whatever the timeframe, Burnham has allowed pro-Europeans to mull a future relationship with the EU which only six months ago would have been unthinkable. Several rejoin figures told The i Paper they would want Labour to get to a commitment in its next manifesto to start formal negotiations with the EU, with the promise that any deal would need government approval, a parliamentary vote and a referendum. A Labour source said: “You need a specific mandate for it.” They suggested Britain could take inspiration from the “incredibly functional” way Iceland had negotiated with the EU and not torn itself apart. Farage: I’m ready for round two For voters and politicians who wince when they remember the bitter divisions of the Brexit years, that might appear optimistic. Given the Brexiteers won in 2016 in part on a message of giving the establishment a kicking, there is already a row brewing over which side can realistically claim to be the insurgents. ‘Stay Out’ is set to be dubbed “the status quo campaign” by allies of Burnham. But Nigel Farage, the so-called godfather of Brexit, has different plans. “The interesting psychological point is now the leavers actually own the status quo. The uncertainty is in rejoining,” the Reform UK Leader told The i Paper. “For me, if there’s a campaign, it’ll be: ‘hold my jacket. I’m ready’.” “The genie is out of the bottle… The debate’s happening. The question is, as the debate grows, where is the enthusiasm? Where is the energy? Who leads it? Farage said. “Burnham has opened up a massive divisive argument, and even if he wants to pull back a bit from it, I don’t think he can,” Farage added.

Original Source

Read the full article at Inews →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.