Sunday Notes: Edgar Martinez and CJ Gillman are Different Spices in Seattle’s New Stew

Sunday Notes: Edgar Martinez and CJ Gillman are Different Spices in Seattle’s New Stew

The Seattle Mariners named Jason Kanzler as their new manager on November 3, entrusting the 36-year-old, erstwhile Chicago Cubs farm director to help turn around an offense that went in the wrong direction this past season. Atypically, the Mariners had decided on a new hitting coach prior to filling their managerial vacancy. On October 30, it became known that CJ Gillman would be returning to replace Kevin Seitzer, who had filled that role in each of the past two campaigns. The 37-year-old Gillman served as Seattle’s minor league hitting coordinator from 2022-2025, then spent last season as the director of hitting for the Washington Nationals. I asked Jerry Dipoto about the change in hitting coaches during the recently-held GM meetings. “It’s really just going back to the future,” Seattle’s president of baseball operations told me. “CJ was our hitting coordinator for four years, so we’re familiar with him. Obviously, Edgar [Martinez] remains a part of our organization and will be influential as a consultant, as he has been for all the years that I’ve been here. Bringing CJ back… it’s just a known. We know what he’s about [and] are aligned with him in the way he thinks about offense. It also happens to align with the way Jason Kanzler thinks about offense. “Jason was very complimentary of CJ throughout the course of his interview process,”Dipoto added. “We had an opportunity to bring him back, and did it. Then, a few days later, Kanz hopped on board. We feel that it’s the right fit.” I proceeded to ask the Mariners’ top executive if Gillman and Martinez — Seattle’s senior director of hitting strategy — approach hitting the same way. “No,” Dipoto replied. “But they work well together. From a teammates, personality, work-ethics standpoint, they are very compatible. They do talk about hitting in different ways, but I think it’s healthy to have people in your environment that come at it from a different angle. In last year’s hitting group we had multiple voices who all came from the same direction… You need different spices to make a good stew.” How do Gillman and Martinez differ in their approaches to hitting? “They’re very different communicators,” Dipoto explained. “I would say that both are more listen than talk. CJ, like Jason, qualifies offense as just touching home plate. His primary approach has been been ‘hit the ball hard and get it in the air.’ Edgar is more methodical, think through it, keep the ball down on a line. Both are right, depending on who is hitting. Each player has his own approach, his own mindset, and needs a coach who can meet him where he’s at. “And then there’s Ichiro [Suzuki],” Dipoto went on to say. “He can go from just about any direction with hitting. Having a smorgasbord of options — but also a very clear understanding of the way we want to play offense, especially in our ballpark. Damage early, discipline late, and get the ball airborne.” ——— RANDOM HITTER-PITCHER MATCHUPS Brett Gardner went 16 for 39 against Félix Hernández. Jay Bruce went 15 for 43 against Lance Lynn. Ryan Zimmerman went 14 for 28 against Chris Volstad. Pablo Sandoval went 13 for 20 against Nathan Eovaldi. Kyle Seager went 12 for 35 against Yu Darvish. ——— Our Atlanta Braves Top Prospects list went up on Wednesday, and a pair of young southpaws are high on the list. Cam Caminiti ranked third, while Briggs McKenzie — featured here at FanGraphs the same day — ranked seventh. How similar are the promising youngsters? I asked that question of Alex Anthopoulos at the GM Meetings. “They are very different,” Atlanta’s president of baseball operations answered. “One has elite spin — that’s McKenzie — and Cam is more power with his stuff. So, the profiles are really different. They’re both really talented, and they’re both really young — they’re [also] high picks in terms of signing bonuses — but their styles are way different. “They’re both strike-throwers,” Anthopoulos added. “I know that Cam’s walk rate looks high [10.9% this past season}, and Briggs’s [11.6% too], but ultimately they’re strike-throwers. Both can really pitch.” Caminiti, who is 20 years old and was drafted 24th overall in 2024 out of a Scottsdale, Arizona high school, is fast approaching Atlanta. McKenzie, who likewise turned 20 this year, was a fourth-round pick in 2025 out of a Wendell, North Carolina high school. He is farther away from the majors. “Briggs didn’t get a lot of innings in the minors, so we put him in the Fall League, even though he’s young, we thought he had enough stuff to compete there,” the executive explained. “Right now, the thought would be that, at the end of the year, he will be in [High-A] Rome. That is [also] where he would start. Caminiti got to Double-A this year, and once you get to Double-A with us, you’re in play for the big-league level. If he performs the way he can, he’ll be in the discussion at some point to hit Atlanta in 2027.” And then there is the organization’s top-rated prospect. I made it a point to also ask about 20-year-old outfielder Eric Hartman. “Electric bat speed,” Anthopoulos said of the St. Albert, Alberta native, whom Atlanta took in the 20th round of the 2024 draft. “Great power. A great runner. He really emerged. He hits the ball exceptionally hard and gets it up in the air. “He can play all three outfield spots,” the Montreal-born-and-raised exec went on to say. “He’s played a lot of center, but we’ve moved him a little bit to left because [Michael] Harris is going to basically anchor center field for us for a long time. If he goes to [Double-A] Columbus and has a good year, he’ll be in play to hit Atlanta at some point in 2027.” ——— A quiz: Steve Barber was the first Baltimore Orioles pitcher to log a 20-win season, doing so in 1963. Who was the second pitcher in Orioles franchise history to achieve that feat? (A hint: he had four 20-win seasons across a 14-year career.) The answer can be found below. ——— NEWS NOTES Tampa Bay Rays announced on Monday that they have promoted Danielle Dockx to senior director of player development. The Princeton University graduate joined the organization in 2018 and has served as director of player programs and integration for each of the past two seasons. Ken Sanders, a right-hander who pitched for eight MLB teams — most notably the Brewers — from 1970-1976, died earlier this week at age 85. A St. Louis native who made all but one of his 409 appearances as a reliever, Sanders recorded 86 saves, 31 of them coming with Milwaukee in his career-best 1971 season. Lance Broadway, a native of Bryan, Texas who pitched for the White Sox (and briefly the Yankees) from 2007-2009, died unexpectedly on Wednesday at age 43. Drafted 15th overall by Chicago in 2005 out of Texas Christian University, the right-hander went 2-2 with a 5.24 ERA over 55 big-league innings. ——— The answer to the quiz is Dave McNally. The southpaw had the first of his four consecutive 20-win seasons in 1968. ——— Nick Krall didn’t seem especially enamored with a question I asked him at the GM Meetings. Prefacing it by noting that Reds batters had MLB’s highest strikeout rate this year, I wanted to know if he could point to a reason for his team’s also logging the lowest BABIP. Was that mostly just a matter of misfortune, or did the root cause lie elsewhere? “Obviously, there is probably some luck in there,” Cincinnati’s president of baseball operations replied. “But we also have to make sure that we’re making better contact with what we’re doing. We weren’t good. We struck out way too many times. We need to cut down our strikeout rate [because] if you put more balls in play, you give yourself more of a chance, too. We just need to get better offensively.” A player that could very well help that happen in the not-too-distant future is Alfredo Duno. Coming off a season where he logged a 130 wRC+ between two levels, the 20-year-old catcher currently ranks 17th on The Board. Following up on my BABIP question, I asked the executive where Duno stands in terms of big-league readiness. “He was our top prospect coming in,” replied Krall. “He was in Double-A, is playing a little bit of winter ball, and hopefully will make some strides. He will probably start the year in the minors.” Playing as one of the youngest players in the Venezuelan Winter League, Duno is slashing .210/.359/.339 over 79 plate appearances with Leones del Caracas. ——— FOREIGN AFFAIRS Roldy Brito is 20-for-66 with a pair of round-trippers — he is also 7-for-7 in steal attempts — for the Dominican Winter League’s Gigantes del Cibao. Ranked third in the Colorado Rockies system at season’s end, the 19-year-old, switch-hitting infielder/outfielder batted .305 with 10 home runs and a 106 wRC+ over 553 plate appearances between Low-A Fresno and High-A Spokane. He also swiped 41 bags. Aaron Schunk is 24-for-71 with a dozen doubles for the Dominican Winter League’s Estrellas Orientales. The 29-year-old former Colorado Rockies infielder finished this past season with the Atlantic League’s Lancaster Stormers after being released by the Atlanta Braves in late July. The Australian Baseball League season got underway earlier this week with the Perth Heat beating the Sydney Blue Sox by a score of 4-0. Kevin Vaupel, a 25-year-old left-hander who was in the Miami Marlins system from 2023-2025, and pitched for the American Association’s Winnipeg Goldeyes this past summer, allowed one hit over six scoreless innings for the prevailing side. The ABL’s other opening match also featured a strong pitching performance. The Brisbane Bandits edged the Adelaide Giants 2-1, with 24-year-old right-hander Kasuga Sakaguchi surrendering a pair of hits over five scoreless frames. Sakaguchi spent this past season with the Yokohama BayStars’ Japan Farm League affiliate. ——— Which catcher is more Hall of Fame worthy, Bill Freehan or Buster Posey? I asked that question in a social media poll a few days ago, and the latter came out on top by a hefty margin. The erstwhile San Francisco Giant garnered 74.5% of the votes cast, while the former Detroit Tiger took home just 25.5%. The results came as little surprise. First-time eligible this year, Posey seems a shoe-in for election. A one-and-done in his lone year on the ballot, Freehan played his last game 50 years ago. An argument could be made that Freehan is every bit as deserving. In a career that was similar in length to Posey’s, the rugged backstop was named to 11 American League All-Star teams over a 12-year stretch. Moreover, he won five Gold Gloves along the way, as well as a World Series ring with the Tigers in 1968. While admittedly not as prolific a hitter as Posey was, he nonetheless accumulated more hits, home runs, and total bases. As for the now-Giants president of baseball operations having a clear edge in fWAR (57.9 to 44.8), it bears noting that his edge in bWAR (45.0 to 44.7) is negligible. Framing is, of course, a big part of that. As we aren’t able to quantify Freehan’s framing skills, a statistical comparison of their defensive value is apples to oranges. A checkmark will go next to Posey’s name on the Hall of Fame ballot that arrived in my mailbox a few days ago. If Freehan were somehow on the ballot, a checkmark would go next to his name, as well. Much like Lou Whitaker, Freehan is a former Tiger whose career accomplishments make him worthy of a plaque in Cooperstown. ——— Sticking with Hall-of-Fame-worthiness comps, Jon Lester tossed 2,740 innings and went 200-117 with a 117 wRC+, while Wes Ferrell tossed 2,623 innings and went 193-128 with a 116 wRC+. In terms of regular-season pitching performances, the two are in close company. Lester is on the ballot for a first time this year, and just how much support he will receive is difficult to predict. Given a weaker-than-usual field, he may actual fare pretty well. As for Ferrell, he played for six teams — mostly the Cleveland Indians and Boston Red Sox — from 1927-1941, and fell well short on both writers ballots and veterans committee ballots. The likelihood of his ever again being considered seems remote. It shouldn’t be. Not only was Ferrell a good pitcher; he ranks among the best-hitting pitchers of all-time. Here is how Ferrell compares to Lester, using bWAR as our barometer: Lester had 43.5 bWAR as a pitcher and minus-0.1 bWAR as a hitter, giving him 43.4 overall. Ferrell had 48.8 bWAR as a pitcher and 11.3 bWAR as a hitter, giving him 61.1 overall. Dozens of pitchers with less total WAR have plaques in Cooperstown. Shouldn’t Ferrell have one as well? ——— A random obscure former player snapshot. Bugs Raymond was the best pitcher on the last St. Louis Cardinals team to suffer a 100-loss season. That was a long time ago. In 1908, the Cardinals went 49-105, with Raymond going 15-25 with a 2.03 ERA over 324-and-a-third innings. The right-hander also logged five shutouts that year, one of them against a New York Giants club that won 98 games and finished one game in arrears of the pennant-winning Chicago Cubs. He became a Giant that same winter. In a four-player swap that brought Hall of Fame catcher/outfielder Roger Bresnahan to the city known as “The Gateway to the West,” Raymond headed east… where he became a burdened-by-alcoholism problem child while playing for legendary manager John McGraw. He performed well on the field in 1909 — a record of 18-12 and a 2.47 ERA — but then things went south. Raymond went just 10-15 over the next two seasons, which were his last in the majors. Tragedy followed. In September 1912, separated from his wife and with their five-year-old daughter having recently died from influenza, Raymond was assaulted with a baseball bat while playing for a semi-pro team in his hometown of Chicago. Shortly thereafter, his body was found in a shabby hotel room; the cause of death was a cerebral hemorrhage due to a fractured skull. Raymond’s SABR BioProject entry is well worth the read. ——— LINKS YOU’LL LIKE The Ringer’s Ben Lindbergh wrote about how expanded playoffs are swallowing sports. The Athletic’s Tyler Kepner saluted the 14 newcomers to the Baseball Hall of Fame ballot. MLB.com’s Mike Petriello looked at five underachievers who might be in line for a Jake Bauers-esque breakout with the bat. Also at MLB.com, Michael Clair wrote about overlooked MLB trailblazer Masanori Murakami, who pitched for the San Francisco Giants in 1964 and 1965. NPB’s top stars are leaving Japan, as are an increasing number of amateur players — a dilemma that has Sadaharu Oh and Hideki Kuriyama calling for change. Jason Coskrey has the story at The Japan Times. ——— RANDOM FACTS AND STATS Dustin May has faced 1,965 batters and has a 4.12 ERA, a 4.04 FIP, and a 22.3% strikeout rate. Bryce Miller has faced 2,118 batters and has a 4.04 ERA, a 4.15 FIP, and a 22.8% strikeout rate. Sonny Gray has pitched in 368 games and gone 143-107 with a 3.51 ERA. Johnny Cueto pitched in 370 games and went 144-113 with a 3.52 ERA. A total of 31 pitchers have been credited with 300 or more saves. Of them, Rollie Fingers recorded the most relief wins (107), while Jason Isringhausen recorded the fewest relief wins (33). Trevor Hoffman appeared in 1,034 games and threw 1,089-and-a-third innings. The Hall of Fame closer was never charged with a balk. The New York Yankees signed Rich Gossage as a free agent on today’s date in 1977. The Goose spent the next six seasons with the Bombers, recording 41 wins and 150 saves, and being named to four All-Star teams. On today’s date in 1920, the Cincinnati Reds acquired right-hander Eppa Rixey from the Philadelphia Phillies in exchange for Greasy Neale and Jimmy Ring. Rixey proceeded to record 179 wins as a Red, the most in franchise history. Players born on today’s date include Lyman Bostock, who was 27 years old and in his fourth MLB season when he was murdered — the assailant was reportedly targeting someone else — in September 1978. A left-handed-hitting outfielder, Bostock had batted .311 with a 122 wRC+ over 2,214 plate appearances while playing for the Minnesota Twins and California Angels. His father, Lyman Bostock Sr, played in the Negro Leagues, primarily with the Birmingham Black Barons. Also born on today’s date was Kevin Rhomberg, an outfielder who got three statistically-stellar cups of coffee with the Cleveland Indians across the 1982-1984 seasons. Over 52 MLB plate appearances, the Dubuque, Iowa native slashed 383/.423/.447 with a 142 wRC+. Just as noteworthy are his litany of superstitious quirks. Among them — per his SABR BioProject entry — if someone touched him, Rhomberg needed to tag that person back.

Original Source

Read the full article at Blogs →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.