William Liang-Imagn Images Back in August, Major League Baseball’s Statcast team unveiled a brand-new leaderboard at Baseball Savant that quantified receiving skills for first basemen. It’s a treasure trove of really cool data, and you can split it up in some really interesting ways. Moreover, it has something for everyone. Even if you’re not particularly concerned with crunching all the numbers to tease out fun baseball facts, it’s still worth it to head over to Savant if you think you might enjoy using it to turn your favorite first baseman into a Rock ‘Em Sock ‘Em Robot: In September, I parsed the data and found that fielders significantly shift their targets based on the height of the first baseman. I intended that to be the first of a whole series of articles digging into scoop data, but then baseball started baseballing. It was time to write about the postseason picture, then the playoffs, then the World Series, and then BLEPH. But I’ve still got a bunch of scoop ideas, and so today I figured I’d start with a very simple question: Who’s better at receiving, right-handed first basemen or left-handed first basemen? If you run the splits, you’ll notice that lefties seem to have significantly better numbers than righties. The data goes back to 2021, and over that period, left-handed first basemen are credited with 4.7 outs above average for their receiving, while righties are at -13.4. That feels like a huge gap, but it’s important to remember that the samples are huge too. We’re talking about just under 124,000 throws. Moreover, this is a counting stat, so it matters that the league has more right-handed first basemen than left-handed ones. Righties have fielded nearly 81% of all the throws, so while their numbers are indeed lower, the difference in sample size is skewing the proportions. Let’s turn this into a rate state by looking at OAA on a per-throw basis. Once we run those numbers, lefties are worth 0.020 runs per 100 throws, while righties are worth -0.013. We’re talking about a difference of 0.033 outs per 100 throws. In 2023, Nathaniel Lowe, who throws right-handed, fielded 749 throws, the most of any player since 2021. Multiply that times 0.033 and divide by 100, and you find that, were the glove on the other hand, we’d expect Lowe to record an extra quarter of an out. If you live in an imaginary world where you have two first basemen who are identical in every way except which hand they throw with, then sure, go with the lefty, who’s likely to earn you an extra scoop once every four years. But in practice, if you’re talking about any one player, these numbers are small enough not to matter. That said, I was still curious about why lefties grade out better than righties. Those huge samples may dilute the topline OAA numbers, but the fact that there’s still a difference at all over such a large and long sample makes me think that maybe there really is something to the numbers. Statcast splits up throws into six categories: High, On Target, Low, Scoop, Bounce, and Wide. The diagram below shows the breakdown: Naturally, these different kinds of throws have different success rates. On-target throws almost always get caught, while bouncers are the toughest. Here’s the breakdown: First Baseman Catch Success Rate (%) On Target Bounce Scoop Low High Wide 98 60 66 86 89 78 Now I’m going to show you how good lefties and righties have been over the course of the past six seasons. Once again, we’ll use OAA per 100 throws in order to compare apples to apples. Just to make things easier, the third row shows the difference between the two, subtracting the righties’ score from the lefties. It shows you how much better lefties are than righties, so if there’s a minus sign, it means righties are better. I’d advise you to direct your eye to the scoop column, as it features the biggest gap by a mile: First Base Receiving Handedness Splits (OAA/100 Throws) Handedness On Target Bounce Scoop Low High Wide Lefties 0.04 0.76 -1.83 -0.54 0.31 -0.03 Righties -0.01 -0.33 0.38 0.05 -0.12 0.02 Difference 0.06 1.10 -2.21 -0.59 0.43 -0.05 As the diagram showed, throws are classified as scoops if their trajectory has them bouncing within five feet of first base, and righties are much, much better at fielding them. You have to feel for those poor right-handed first basemen. Statcast finally releases scoop data, and they’re way better at the balls actually classified as scoops, but somehow they’re still worse overall! Honestly, I’m not sure how to make much sense of this breakdown. The gaps for on-target and wide throws are tiny. Lefties are better at high throws, while righties are better at low throws and scoops. Then lefties are better at bounces. Maybe there’s something real here, in that lefties are better at higher throws and righties are generally better at lower ones. But it’s certainly not a tidy narrative, and if you add up all the numbers in the bottom row except for the first column – in other words, if you ignore on-target throws and just look at who’s better at fielding imperfect throws – you’ll find that righties are actually better than lefties by a factor of 1.32 outs per 100. In other words, righties are, on the whole, better at catching difficult throws. In fact, they’re so much better that it’s true even if you stop turning OAA into a rate state and just look at the overall numbers. Everybody grades out badly on off-target throws, but over the past six seasons, even though they’ve seen nearly five times as many bad throws, righties have put up a total of -3.83 OAA on them, while lefties have put up -4.11. Another way to say this: Lefties are only better than righties because they’re racking up value on easy throws. As we’ve already established, chances aren’t split up evenly. Righties are better at low throws and scoops, but those are the two rarest kinds of throws. Just over 80% of throws are on target, and lefties are slightly better at receiving on-target throws, though it’s not just about the fact that they’re better. They also get more on-target throws, and on-target throws get caught over 98% of the time, while other throws get caught just under 78% of the time: First Base Receiving Distribution Handedness On Target Bounce Scoop Low High Wide Lefties 82.7 3.1 2.1 3.1 5.1 4.0 Righties 80.8 2.9 2.4 3.0 5.1 5.7 That first column, which shows that lefties have a higher on-target throw rate by 1.83 percentage points, is the whole story. Lefties have graded out better at receiving because they have gotten easier chances than righties. As we established back in August, who the first baseman is can definitely affect the quality of the chances you get. If you’re short, you’ll get lower throws. So perhaps there is something about left-handed first basemen, or the way they present their target, that causes the other infielders to be more accurate with their throws. But I’m not positive about that either, because it didn’t always work that way: First Basemen Receiving OAA OAA Left Right 2021 -15 8 2022 7 -24 2023 -1 1 2024 -7 15 2025 12 8 2026 9 -5 If you break the numbers down by year, you’ll find that from 2021 to 2024, right-handed first basemen broke even on receiving with zero OAA, while lefties were at -16. Then things completely turned around in 2025. Over the past two years, lefties are at +21 OAA, while righties are at +3. So maybe we shouldn’t put too much stock in the overall numbers. Statcast says that lefties had a lower expected out rate than righties in 2021, 2023, and 2024, but then that flipped in the last two seasons. So maybe that’s where much of the discrepancy is coming in. For a while, righties had slightly easier chances, so they put up better numbers, then lefties got slightly easier chances, and the numbers flipped. As you might recall, 2023 wasn’t exactly a normal year. That was the first year of the infield shift ban. All of a sudden, teams couldn’t overload the right side of the infield. Shortstops could only cheat so far up the middle. And wouldn’t you know it, right when the shift ban was introduced, the makeup of the throws first basemen received started changing. The graph below shows the percentage of groundballs hit to each of the other three infield positions, which is a good proxy for the makeup of the throws first basemen have seen: Starting in 2023, a much higher percentage of throws has come from second base, mostly at the expense of shortstop. In fact, 2026 was the first year that second basemen were busier than shortstops. But what’s weird is that righties are actually better at fielding throws from second base and worse on throws from the left side of the diamond: First Base Receiving OAA/100 by Position Handedness 2B SS 3B Lefties 0.07 0.02 -0.06 Righties 0.10 -0.02 -0.13 Second basemen are getting more chances, and right-handed first basemen are better at fielding throws from second basemen. They’re the ones whose numbers should be getting better! So I don’t know what to tell you. Clearly, even though we’re working with six years of data, the differences are small enough that not all of them are statistically significant. However, the gap in terms of on-target throws is very real. In each of the past six seasons, lefties have had a higher on-target rate than righties by at least 0.8 percentage points, and sometimes more than quadruple that amount: This is all confusing, so let’s recap. The first takeaway is that a lot of these splits are noisy. We might have to wait for a few more years to see if we can trust them. Left-handed first basemen have slightly better numbers than righties, but we probably shouldn’t take those numbers to mean that they’re actually better than righties. However, it does seem safe to say that righties are actually better than lefties at fielding tough throws. The reason lefties have better numbers right now is that they really do seem to have some power that allows them to induce more on-target throws from their fellow infielders. It’s weird, but then again, so is baseball.
Righty First Basemen Are Better Than Lefties at Scoops, but They’re Worse at Receiving
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Blogs →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.