Patrick Breen-USA TODAY NETWORK If you were on X, formerly known as Twitter, over the weekend, you might’ve seen a five-minute video posted to Major League Baseball’s official account. Baseball fans have repeatedly told us they have two issues with the game today: blackouts and fairness We’re proposing to make three major changes to baseball: 1. Entering into a partnership with players where all revenues that are generated are split 50/50 between the teams… pic.twitter.com/GgeKshvFmN — MLB (@MLB) November 13, 2026 It starts with a man staring right down the barrel of the camera, like Nietszche’s abyss. You might not know that face, but you should know the name: Morgan Sword. I’ll let Sword introduce himself: “My name is Morgan Sword. I’m the executive vice president of baseball operations at Major League Baseball. My group is responsible for the competitive system in baseball—all the different ways teams compete with each other, on and off the field.” Sword isn’t one of the eight luminaries, including Commissioner Rob Manfred himself, with a mugshot on MLB.com’s Executives page, but few people on the league’s payroll have more pull in terms of what the sport looks like. Indeed, he’s among the favorites to replace Manfred upon his scheduled retirement in 2029. Manfred isn’t exactly a popular figure among baseball fans, which isn’t surprising. It’s part and parcel of the major league commissioner job to be a sin eater for the owners, and to wear the grievances of the fans. And believe you me, baseball fans love being aggrieved. Nevertheless, an appearance by Manfred has often presaged bad news — the 2021-22 lockout, baseball’s only de jure work stoppage since 1995. Plus the capital strike that nearly killed free agency in the late 2010s, and the slow-walked return to play from COVID in 2020, which was a dress rehearsal for the lockout(s) to come. Sword, on the other hand, presents himself as the solutions guy. Take it from him: “We’ve spent the last couple years making changes to the game based on fan feedback. We brought in the pitch clock in 2023, which has revived the stolen base and made games 25 minutes shorter. Fans told us they wanted more accurate ball/strike call[s], so this season we rolled out ABS challenge[s], which allows players to correct the handful of big missed calls that happen throughout the game.” I’m glad Sword mentioned all this up top. This video resembles nothing so much as a political issue ad, and what better way to build trust with the electorate than to list one’s achievements. The pitch clock and the challenge system have both been rousing successes. They’ve allowed a hitherto sclerotic game to adapt to a modern audience, and increased fan trust in officiating. Above all, they’ve cut out a lot of extraneous nonsense from the game. It’s a good foundation to run on, and the perfect introduction for this new face for the league. Manfred is the stick guy, so why not have Sword be the carrot guy? The younger, friendlier messenger who can lay out management’s bargaining position from a position of wanting competitive fairness. I’ve been writing about labor relations in baseball on and off for more than 10 years now. If you’ve read any of that work, you probably know that I’m a left-wing pinko egghead who thinks capitalism is a death cult and all corporate profit is tantamount to wage theft. How could I possibly give the league’s message a fair hearing? It might surprise you to learn, then, that in general, I’m a big fan of Sword’s work. He and his team have been forward-thinking but not rash. Two years ago, when everyone was losing their minds about the Golden At-Bat proposal, I praised Manfred, Sword, and MLB’s rule-makers for their judicious process. They hear every idea, no matter how out there it is, but only implement a few after years of discussion and rigorous minor league testing. When it comes to, in Sword’s words, the different ways teams compete with each other, they’ve earned the benefit of the doubt. I was on board with the pitch clock on Day 1, but other reforms, like ABS and the 12-team playoff format, won me over after initial skepticism. If Sword has ideas on how to improve the sport going forward, we should hear him out. After presenting himself and stating his credentials, Sword launched into his message proper: Addressing what he understands to be fans’ two biggest issues, namely blackouts and fairness. To address these conditions, MLB proposes an even 30-way split for all media revenue among the various teams. You can’t make the playing field truly level; athletes would usually rather live in Los Angeles than Milwaukee (I, personally, would pick the latter every time, but there’s no accounting for taste). Teams that play in bigger cities — especially ones with high population density — are going to have an easier time selling tickets no matter what. Whatever the polls say, I’m not convinced fans actually want true competitive balance. But an even 30-way split on media revenue would make the playing field more level than it is now. The fight might not be equal between the Dodgers and Pirates, but it would be fairer. And the full centralization of local media would, as Sword says, help the league reduce the number of blackouts. When I lived in Columbus, Ohio, two hours from the nearest major league ballpark, my MLB.TV was blacked out of games in Cleveland, Cincinnati, and Pittsburgh. I could get the former two clubs on cable, but not the latter. (And this was during one of the few periods in baseball history in which being blacked out of watching Pirates games was not an act of mercy.) Fans in other parts of the country have it far worse. They’re right to be up in arms about this, and any help would be welcome. MLB’s proposals also raise the minimum salary from $780,000 to $1 million for players with at least a year of service time. One way to help free agents would be to make rookies and replacement-level players more expensive. Here’s the best part about these proposals: MLB doesn’t need to lock out the players to address blackouts and competitive balance. Its owners can share money among themselves as they please. In fact, the union is already on board, having made a more equitable revenue sharing plan a key plank in its own platform. The minimum salary is a mandatory subject of bargaining, so the MLBPA would need to sign off, but it’s hard to imagine the union objecting. These are in line with numerous other ideas set forth by the owners: Changes to the free agency schedule and injured list timing. More aggressive timelines for free agency and the Rule 5 draft to increase player mobility. A return to a 154-game schedule to facilitate a best-of-seven Division Series. All interesting ideas. All conditioned on the players accepting a salary cap, which makes them all nonstarters. The union won’t agree to a salary cap under any circumstances, no matter what other incentives get dangled. Here I’ll restate what I wrote on the subject in August: Only one Big Four sports league has imposed a salary cap on its union in the 21st Century. The NHL got its salary cap, and severe salary rollbacks, but not until it broke the union. And that took canceling an entire season, which damaged the sport in ways from which it still has not recovered 20 years later. It’s going to take at least one lost season to break the MLBPA, maybe more, and I have no idea whether the owners have the stomach for that intense a fight. I’m not sure the owners themselves know at this point; that’s the kind of thing we won’t be able to get a read on until next February or March at the earliest. Until then, we can treat any proposal that’s contingent on a cap-and-floor system as DOA. As progressive as Sword’s been regarding on-field matters, that line remains the same: No fix for blackouts, or for competitive balance, unless the players agree to limit their own wages, and fight each other for part of a fixed share of the pie. The result of that negotiating line from the owners is obvious: Another lockout. Another problem they don’t need the players’ help to avoid. Take it from agent Joel Wolfe, who summed up the situation to The Athletic far more pithily than I could. Said Wolfe: “I find it incredibly obtuse and offensive that the commissioner’s office is scheduling a lockout like it’s some sort of wedding or bar mitzvah. Instead of taking the best minds in baseball — GMs and presidents of baseball, people in the front offices and some at the union — and doing this quietly and saying let’s put our heads together to get something done, he’s going on a PR campaign trying to sell something no one wants to hear and no one wants to buy.” At the time, I thought “something no one wants to hear and no one wants to buy,” was a bit hyperbolic, but the Sword video changed my mind. This clear, concise, friendly presentation was posted to a social media site that should’ve provided a friendly audience. Whatever X used to be, it’s now the Western World’s leading clearinghouse for inhuman capitalist drivel and right-wing agitprop. And they weren’t even buying it there. I scrolled the replies and quote posts for quite a while and couldn’t find a favorable response. One rebuttal by MLB pitcher Jameson Taillon out-liked the original video three-to-one. (To be fair, Taillon’s post went over better than the original video, but not by much. I guess X is just full of people who like to fight.) The league wants a salary cap system based on a 50/50 revenue split between the players and owners. That number was basically picked out of thin air to seem fair. I won’t fact-check the rest of the video, even though, for instance, one might be compelled to wonder how there’s a $446 million gap between the highest and lowest payrolls in the league when the highest payroll last season was $422 million. That’s a project for another time. I’m more interested in a different question. In a hypothetical 50/50 split, the players earn their half because they are the product. Without them, there is no game. What are the owners doing that merits half of the proceeds of the players’ labor? This isn’t a factory; they’re not providing raw material that the players then turn into a tangible product. Increasingly, they’re not even providing the ballparks the games are staged in — they want, and all too often get, taxpayer subsidies for their real estate investments. The owners, or at least the teams, are definitely providing something. They front the cost for gameday operations, pay the lawyers who negotiate marketing and media rights arrangements, hire coaches and general managers and front office staff. They fund player development and invest in technology that brought us cool stuff like Statcast and MLB.TV. They pay people like Morgan Sword and his team to think up and test ways to make the game fairer to play and more exciting to watch. All of that’s valuable, but it’s the work of middlemen. Worse than that, it’s the work of people who hire the middlemen. Half of the league’s revenue goes to the people who play the game and provide all the entertainment value. The other half goes to people who cause the problems this proposal would purport to solve: Absentee owners who field uncompetitive teams. Blackouts, lockouts, extortionate ticket prices, corporate partnerships with companies that make barely-edible $9 hot dogs and produce shoddy $150 replica jerseys. Sword is a smart guy, and as is so often the case, he’s right on the money in this video. Fans want a fairer, more accessible game. It’s just not clear how locking out the players, and threatening to imperil the 2027 season, serves those ends.
Major League Baseball Knows What Its Problems Are, and It Doesn’t Need a Lockout To Fix Them
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Blogs →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.