In True Theater-Kid Fashion, Rachel Zegler’s Dating History Is Full of Her Co-Stars

Every theater kid knows their way around a showmance. If you haven’t spent most of your life at rehearsals or at theater camp, let me explain: You can’t help but fall for the people you run lines and block scenes with! And no matter how much Broadway/West End fame she has, Cosmo cover girl Rachel Zegler is no exception.As Rachel sparks new romance rumors with West End actor Bradley Jordan, her past romances with co-stars and backup dancers prove that she’s a theater kid at heart. A quick scroll through Rachel Zegler’s dating history will show you exactly what I mean.Jump to:Josh Andrés Rivera: 2021–2024Nathan Louis-Fernand: 2025–20262026: (Maybe) Bradley JordanJosh Andrés Rivera: 2021–2024Nina Westervelt//Getty ImagesRachel’s most public relationship was with her co-star-turned-IRL-boyfriend, Josh Andrés Rivera. The pair met on set for Steven Spielberg’s West Side Story remake in July 2019, but sparked dating rumors in February 2021, when Rachel confessed her love for him on social media.I mean, it could have been platonic, but then they fully hard-launched in December that same year…The pair went on to work together again in The Hunger Games: The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes, which resulted in a lot of public appearances and cute red carpet PDA.Eamonn M. McCormack//Getty ImagesHowever, in July 2025, a source confirmed to Us Weekly that after three years together, the pair had “quietly” gone their separate ways in late 2024.Nathan Louis-Fernand: 2025–2026Getty ImagesAnother year, another showmance. This time, Rachel was romantically linked to one of her Evita backup dancers, Nathan Louis-Fernand, after they crossed paths during the production. A source later told People that they “had an instant connection” and “started dating early summer.” They shared that Rachel “brings a very energetic and passionate energy to [Evita]. Nathan’s attracted to this.”Rumors initially circulated when they were spotted kissing at Sabrina Carpenter’s Hyde Park concert in July 2025. Two days after the Daily Mail ran photos of the pair’s PDA, she confirmed their relationship with a selfie sandwiched in a photo dump.instagramHowever, their showmance seemingly came to an end in March 2026, when Rachel shared another photo dump featuring lyrics from Billie Eilish’s “L’AMOUR DE MA VIE”: “I’m so glad it’s over / You were so mediocre.”She also dropped a telling meme on another slide, which reads, “I can’t wait to be a girlfriend cause last time I was the boyfriend.”InstagramWell, then!2026: (Maybe) Bradley JordanGetty ImagesIt’s unclear how these two are even connected, but Rachel’s latest rumored romance does have ties to the theater community. She sparked dating rumors with West End actor Bradley Jordan as they held hands during a stroll through the West Village in NYC, per pics published by SplashNews on September 21.There’s not much out there on the nature of their relationship (or if there even is one), but Bradley is set to make his Broadway debut in Wanted next month.