In this Florida district, politicians battle over who most loves Israel

OCTOBER 21, 2026 15:58Rep. Jared Moskowitz said that he is “proud to be known as the most pro-Israel Jewish Democrat in Congress” during a synagogue event in one of the country’s most Jewish congressional districts on Tuesday evening.The comment came during a one-hour candidates’ forum featuring Moskowitz and his Republican challenger, Scott Singer, both Jewish and wearing kippahs, that largely centered on Israel and grew testy at times.Moskowitz said he is “proud to have AIPAC’s endorsement” at a moment when the popularity of Israel and the pro-Israel lobbying group AIPAC has plummeted among Democratic voters amid Israel’s military campaign in Gaza and the war with Iran. But the crowd at the Reform synagogue Congregation B’nai Israel in Boca Raton was, like Florida’s 25th Congressional District, split across party lines and staunchly pro-Israel.“This isn’t New York, this isn’t Boston, this is South Florida,” attendee Edward Kone told the Jewish Telegraphic Agency. Rep. Jared Moskowitz (D-FL) listens to testimony during a House Oversight and Accountability Committee hearing as part of the House of Republicans' impeachment probe into U.S. President Joe Biden, on Capitol Hill in Washington, US, March 20, 2024. (credit: REUTERS/AMANDA ANDRADE-RHOADES)Florida's recently redrawn 25th Congressional DistrictMoskowitz soundly defeated Democratic Socialist challenger Oliver Larkin, a sharp Israel critic, in August. As Democrats look to take control of the House of Representatives, Florida’s recently redrawn 25th Congressional District, which would have favored Trump by 9 percentage points in 2024 but backed Joe Biden in 2020 under its new boundaries, is being closely watched ahead of the Nov. 3 midterm elections.Despite some tense moments between Moskowitz and Singer, who was Boca Raton’s mayor until earlier this year, the two politicians have been largely aligned on the issue of Israel.Both have condemned accusations that Israel has committed genocide against Palestinians in Gaza. They each oppose any effort to condition or cut off US military aid to Israel. Both supported Israel’s strikes on Iranian facilities in 2025, though Moskowitz has since called for the US to end its war with Iran.Moskowitz referenced his and Singer’s shared pro-Israel viewpoints on Tuesday during the forum moderated by South Florida Sun Sentinel journalist Anthony Man.“This is exactly why nothing gets done in Washington. This is exactly why nothing is functioning: Because literally two people who agree on 99% of this stuff want to take this 1% and try to ram it down people’s throats,” Moskowitz said.Singer, however, emphasized where the two candidates differ on Israel. He criticized Moskowitz for voting for the March 2026 war powers resolution in response to the Trump administration ordering strikes on Iran without congressional authorization. While Moskowitz has called for the administration to end the war, Singer argued that the threat of Iran must be thoroughly dealt with. “We have to ensure victory here,” he said.'America first, but Israel is extremely important to me'For siblings Edward and Susan Kone, both Jewish Republican voters who attended the forum, Moskowitz’s record on Israel does not stack up against Singer’s positions. They also criticized Moskowitz for voting to end the Iran war and for his 2023 vote to keep Minnesota Rep. Ilhan Omar on the Foreign Affairs Committee.“I’m America first, but Israel is extremely important to me. And on Israel, Jared Moskowitz just doesn’t add up,” Edward Kone said. Omar is among a number of pro-Palestinian Democrats whom Republicans say are leading the party’s left-wing flank in turning it against Israel.Singer himself blasted Moskowitz for voting against removing Omar and tied him to the left flank of the Democratic Party.“The strategy is adjective, verb, Ilhan Omar, I got it. Let’s move on to the next topic,” Moskowitz responded, drawing some groans from the audience.Others in the room had voted for Moskowitz in previous elections, and said they were likely to do so again, at least in part because of his Israel stance.“He has a good track record with Israel, and as an American Jew I appreciate that,” said Peter Davidson, an independent who is a member of Congregation B’nai Israel.Moskowitz pointed to AIPAC's endorsement and Singer’s lack of an endorsement from Rep. Randy Fine, a fellow Jewish Republican from Florida, as evidence that he is seen as sufficiently pro-Israel across parts of the political spectrum. He also pointed to a post on X by Jeff Miller, an RJC board member, who wrote that he has “zero interest in tearing down one of the few Democrats left willing to stand unapologetically with America and Israel.”“They’re staying out,” Moskowitz said. “They’re specifically saying, ‘We’re not going to oppose Jared Moskowitz because of his record fighting antisemitism and fighting for the State of Israel.’”Singer has the endorsement of the RJC and Trump as well. He admitted during the forum that he had reached out to Fine for an endorsement and was rejected.Earlier this year, Singer downplayed anti-Israel trends on the right as “a few fringe commentators” who are out of step with Trump. Moskowitz challenged him to name three of those figures: Tucker Carlson, Candace Owens and Florida gubernatorial candidate James Fishback.Singer named all three and said “I gladly, shamelessly condemn” them, but countered that Democrats are voting in anti-Israel voices while Republicans cast theirs aside.Man also asked Singer about President Donald Trump’s use of the term “Shylock” on Monday, a term that references a character from the play “The Merchant of Venice,” which is rooted in an antisemitic trope.“I think that’s an ill-advised term,” Singer said, before pivoting to praise of Trump and urging the audience to focus on what the president has done for Israel rather than his choice of words.“‘Merchant of Venice’ happens to be my favorite Shakespeare play. That term has multiple meanings. But let’s look at the real record beyond an offhand comment: No president has been better for the State of Israel than President Trump,” Singer said, drawing applause.As for the upcoming Israeli elections, which Trump recently weighed in on, Singer told reporters after the event that he was too busy with his own race to endorse candidates and has no preferred candidate.“To be candid, I have some awareness of it, but I’m not following it intently,” he said.Singer’s attacks on Tuesday often focused on Moskowitz’s Democratic Party, which he says will drown out the congressman’s pro-Israel views as it takes its cues from its left-wing flank. He pointed to Moskowitz’s quote from last month, when he said that pro-Israel voices are being “ostracized” in the party.“It’s great that he says these things, but he’s also voted to empower Ilhan Omar twice,” Singer said. “He’s tried to go along to get along with the Squad, and it’s not working.”But for some in the crowd, that attack didn’t quite land.Davidson, an independent, said he is “not a great fan” of the Democratic Party. But for him, Moskowitz is an exception.“He’s more of an independent thinker,” Davidson said. “Crosses a lot of party lines.”Follow us on Google