From Michigan to the Knesset: What two elections revealed about pride and promises - opinion

From Michigan to the Knesset: What two elections revealed about pride and promises - opinion

Jerusalem Post/OpinionIf all else fails, we can always be assured that we will find another crisis that will make us forget this one.Follow us on GoogleUS SENATOR-ELECT Abdul El-Sayed of Michigan attends a weekly Democrat policy luncheon on Capitol Hill in Washington, Nov. 10. (photo credit: Elizabeth Frantz/Reuters)NOVEMBER 22, 2026 00:03Yes, the voting is over – both in Israel and the US – and the counting is done, but the “fun” is just beginning. The ramifications and repercussions of this seminal election stand to affect generations to come in ways that we can hardly imagine. The close and crucial relationship between our two nations has put us at a unique crossroads, where what happens there impacts what happens here – and vice-versa. So let us focus on just a few of the points to consider.In your face!The senator-elect from Michigan – in perhaps the most-watched and most crucial of the night’s contests – began his victory speech with the words, “My name is Abdulrahman Mohamed El-Sayed.” He also boldly threw in a few Arabic phrases such as inshallah (God willing), alhamdulillah (praise be to God), and habibi (my dear). There is no doubt that El-Sayed – though born and raised in Michigan, including by a grandmother who was a member of the Daughters of the American Revolution – was using the opportunity to make one point very clear: Muslims have made it in America.Now, El-Sayed certainly won the election and earned the right to speak, but ask yourself, “If you, a Jew, had won, would you have introduced yourself to the world as Chayim Moishe haKohen?"El-Sayed was, in effect, throwing down the gauntlet to America at large, telling all in an “in-your-face” proclamation that “our time has come.” El-Sayed knows full well that sentiment in America has swung violently (literally!) from admiration and support for Israel and the Jews to backing – at least vocally – for Muslims and Palestinians. This includes Hamas, which just a few months ago was acknowledged as a successor to the Nazis, openly calling for the extermination of the Jews and the Jewish nation. El-Sayed, the Progressive Democrats, the “Squad,” and their ilk are unabashedly pushing their extreme agenda; their outright enthusiasm and display of bold confidence have touched a dangerous nerve among young Americans.My question to the Jews of the States – and Europe, Canada, Australia, et al. – is: how open, obvious, and proud will you be in your Jewishness? We all know about the highly secretive payes-under-the-baseball cap disguise, but how far will this go? Will you take the mezuzah down from your doorpost, then paint over the place it once occupied? Will you refrain from frequenting kosher restaurants or openly saying Hebrew blessings where others can hear you? Will you hide your Magen David or Chai necklace; will you still keep your hanukkia (based on one of Israel’s main symbols) in the window and build your sukkah, even in mixed neighborhoods?Signs in support of Abdul El-Sayed, a candidate for the US Senate in Michigan, at Riverside Marina in Detroit, Michigan, US, October 16, 2026. (credit: EMILY ELCONIN/REUTERS)Perhaps, ironically, El-Sayed has told us exactly what we, too, should do: show our Jewishness and our “Israel-ness” openly, unflinchingly, proudly. Don’t shove it in a back pocket or flinch when asked. Because people who hide their identity are sending the message that they indeed have something to hide.What goes aroundSen. Chuck Schumer is the highest-ranking Jewish elected official in US history. He has always prided himself on being a defender of Jewish interests, even coyly suggesting that his name “Schumer” connects to “shomer,” a guardian and protector of Israel and the Jews. But as the Democratic Party has begun to shift its support for Israel, Schumer has become more and more critical of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and the Israeli government, and its policies in the war against Hamas.He lambasted Democratic US Rep. Haley Stevens of Michigan for “betraying the party” by supporting the Republican opponent of El-Sayed, whom Stevens accused of being in company with outright antisemites. Schumer urged Jewish Michiganers (not sure, after this election, just how that term should be pronounced!) to support El-Sayed, and, sadly, a majority heeded his request.But now, Schumer is fighting against his fellow Jewish Democrats as he seeks the prestigious post of Senate majority leader. Sens. Bernie Sanders and Elissa Slotkin have already backed Maryland Sen. Chris Van Hollen for the position, and even El-Sayed has refused to endorse Schumer. Even if he does receive the position in the secret ballot on December 1, Schumer will have shown that he values his politics over his people.Is Israel a democracy?Woody Allen was once asked what religion he is. He answered, “Jewish – with an explanation!” Technically, Israel is a parliamentary democracy, significantly based on the British system of government. But I have always maintained that Israel is a true democracy on one day, and one day only – Election Day. On that day, we truly have the right (or better, obligation) to vote for the party of our choice. But that’s it; from that day on, the party we supported, within the coalition it joins, will do exactly whatever it feels like doing, with no repercussion or recourse – until the next election.That is exactly what is happening as I write these words. Candidates who espoused specific, rigid principles – on the basis of which they earned our votes – now feel free to do whatever they wish. So, as neither bloc has sufficient numbers to form a government, the unthinkable becomes eminently thinkable. Gadi Eisenkot, and especially Avigdor Liberman – both of whom centered their campaign on the principle of universal conscription – have now indicated they will compromise that principle in return for haredi votes (Naftali Bennett, as of today, has not joined in this capitulation). Yes, they admit they promised certain things in the campaign, but, well, you know, “the nation comes first.” Not exactly, guys. It seems that you come first; we’re actually a distant second.The lira trumps loyaltyAs of this writing, the haredi parties are hedging their bets, keeping their cards close to their chests and holding out for the best offer they can get. While it’s part of our Israeli makeup to be cynical, I still find it incredible – and sad – that after decades of being paid off and pampered by the Netanyahu government, which gave a blank check to support their every institution while their 18-year-olds cavalierly dodged the draft, they have no gratitude whatsoever for their former benefactors. While I certainly deplore their unholy alliance, the fact that they would discard Bibi’s passionate pleas for support and sell their votes to the highest bidder is truly repulsive.We call these political factions “parties,” yet that word’s usual association with frivolity, celebration, and merry-making just doesn’t seem to be a very good fit. Still, even with all of these somewhat disconcerting election thoughts, I maintain that A) the only worse forms of government than democracy are all the other systems and B) the nation will muddle through this election marathon – and the next and the next, if they follow – and we shall emerge intact, with the help of God.And if all else fails, we can always be assured that we will find another crisis that will make us forget this one.■ The writer is director of the Jewish Outreach Center of Ra’anana. rabbistewart@gmail.com Follow us on Google

Original Source

Read the full article at Jpost →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.