Carlsen forfeits games against Bibisara, sparks controversy at Total Chess

Carlsen forfeits games against Bibisara, sparks controversy at Total Chess

World No.1 Magnus Carlsen sparked controversy at the Total Chess World Championship Tour Pilot after forfeiting his Fast Classic games against Bibisara Assaubayeva on consecutive days, despite his opponent waiting for him in the playing hall.Magnus Carlsen forfeits Bibisara games, faces favouritism claims at Total Chess (Photo Reuters)New Delhi,Nov 19, 2026 05:19 ISTWorld No.1 Magnus Carlsen found himself at the centre of a controversy at the Total Chess World Championship Tour Pilot after forfeiting his Fast Classic games against Bibisara Assaubayeva on both days of their two-day fixture.Carlsen walked away from the playing hall after taking an unassailable lead in the tie, leaving Bibisara waiting for him. The Norwegian spoke to the arbiter before leaving but did not inform his opponent of his decision.Out of title contention and playing for a 17th-place finish, Carlsen had built an 11-point lead on Tuesday by winning three of the four blitz games and two rapid games against Bibisara.He repeated the decision on Wednesday after collecting 10 points from the four blitz and two rapid games. Bibisara was awarded all eight points on offer on both days. However, Carlsen still won the tie, having taken the opening day's fixture 11.5-8.5 before the second day ended in a 10-10 draw.Carlsen defended his decision, saying there was little point in playing the classical game once the result was decided. "There will be no classical game as I understood, the match is over. The only consequence of not showing up is that you will lose a totally meaningless game," Carlsen was quoted as saying by Norwegian broadcaster TV2 on Tuesday."I think that if you play a World Championship and it counts for points and such, I can understand."His decision came at a time when his rating was also under pressure. A draw or defeat in the Fast Classic game would have taken Carlsen below the 2800 Elo mark for the first time in almost 17 years. The Norwegian has remained above 2800 since 2009.Carlsen has struggled in the Fast Classic format at the Budapest pilot. He finished fifth in his group after managing nine draws and one defeat, against Armenia's Haik Martirosyan, in 10 games. He lost 21.8 rating points over the past week.The Norwegian could also be at risk of losing the world No.1 ranking, which he has held for more than 15 years.Earlier on Tuesday, Carlsen had made it clear that he was not keen on playing another classical game in the classification match."This is an awkward situation to be in, I would rather not play that much more classical anymore," he said.TOTAL CHESS TO REVIEW FORMAT AFTER BUDAPESTTotal Chess CEO Kjell Madland said the Budapest pilot would help organisers assess the format and make changes, if required, before the inaugural edition in March 2027."The Budapest pilot is an important learning exercise for Total Chess. While we have developed the format and regulations with considerable thought and input, the real test is how they work in a live competitive environment."We want to hear directly from the players and arbiters, understand their experiences and take on board constructive feedback."Our objective is to assess whether any refinements are required before the inaugural edition in March 2027. We are not approaching this with a predetermined view that the rules need to change; rather, we want to ensure that we have tested the format thoroughly and are taking the best possible version of it into its inaugural season," Madland said in a statement.The organisers could not immediately confirm whether Carlsen would face an automatic fine for forfeiting the games.NIEMANN ACCUSES ORGANISERS OF FAVOURITISMCarlsen's decision drew criticism from American Grandmaster Hans Niemann, who is also competing at the event. Niemann accused the organisers of showing preferential treatment towards the Norwegian and questioned whether another player would have received the same leeway."Whether games could count even after the match was over was discussed and agreed upon in the technical meeting. If Carlsen was playing someone with a higher rating, he might have been more inclined to play."Nevertheless, if any other player forfeited a game, disrespecting the organiser and his opponent, they would have lost the match by forfeit. It's incredibly disappointing to see continued favouritism towards one player. Let's not forget the jeans, and 'Co World Champion' saga. All rules must be applied equally, regardless of the player. End of story," Niemann wrote on X.FIDE Chief Executive Adviser Emil Sutovsky also criticised Carlsen's actions. "Hard to comment on such a pathetic unsportsmanlike conduct," he posted.India's Olympiad chess captain Srinath Narayanan also took a dig at the Norwegian, writing on X: "Dignity and courtesy took a fall long before the rating."- Ends

Original Source

Read the full article at Indiatoday →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.