Avigdor Liberman's flip-flop on haredi draft exemptions exposes his political opportunism - opinion

Avigdor Liberman's flip-flop on haredi draft exemptions exposes his political opportunism - opinion

NOVEMBER 20, 2026 17:42Watching Avigdor Liberman somersault from savaging the haredi (ultra-Orthodox) public to courting it leaves one reeling from acute whiplash.This is no mere awkward volte-face but rather a calculated maneuver by a politician who has long exploited the haredi draft issue for his own ends. It is political prostitution par excellence, shameless swashbuckling of the worst kind.The record shows that Liberman will say or do whatever suits him, however contradictory or destructive his actions may be. The only consistency in Liberman’s behavior is his penchant for sabotage of anything associated with Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.In the current context, Liberman also seeks to emasculate Gadi Eisenkot, the “change” camp’s would-be leader, and position himself as the heir apparent if both Netanyahu and Eisenkot fail to form a coalition government.Since 2019, when Liberman set himself up as the great savior of secular Israel, he has repeatedly pushed Israel into utterly unnecessary election campaigns over the haredi draft issue. These campaigns produced months and then years of government paralysis and a torrent of hateful election rhetoric.MKs Naftali Bennett, Yair Lapid, and Avigdor Liberman seen during the inaugural session of the 26th Knesset, in Jerusalem, November 10, 2026 (credit: MARC ISRAEL SELLEM/THE JERUSALEM POST)Of course, Liberman never had the slightest idea how to persuade haredi Jews to enlist in the army. His decision to go to the barricades over this issue, even to the point of forcing repeated elections, was and remains little more than pompous posturing – a political cockfight designed to draw Netanyahu’s blood.Thus, the sensitive issue of haredi military service, which demands a realistic solution, has been reduced to a political football.Now, in late 2026, we are supposed to believe that Liberman is the great savior of the change bloc, as he panders to haredi politicians in a way that might run Netanyahu out of town. But once again, Liberman’s maneuver is a feint – a cynical political scheme destined to fail and designed primarily to trip up Eisenkot.Then Liberman will say to Eisenkot (and to Yair Golan, Yair Lapid, and Naftali Bennett): You failed; it is now my time to lead.A record of political defectionsRemember: Liberman is a serial coalition deserter – a political partner who cannot be trusted.In 1997, he resigned as director general of Netanyahu’s Prime Minister’s Office, accusing the latter of lying and being a closet “leftist.” In 2002, Liberman resigned from the cabinet over Israeli acceptance of US President George W. Bush’s “road map” for peace with the Palestinians. In 2005, he resigned in protest of prime minister Ariel Sharon’s disengagement from Gaza.In 2008, he resigned in protest over prime minister Ehud Olmert’s concessions to Mahmoud Abbas of the Palestinian Authority. In 2018, he resigned from the post of defense minister to protest Israel’s “restraint” after an upswing in rocket attacks from Gaza.You might be tempted to see a consistent set of diplomatic and defense principles behind Liberman’s resignations, but that would be a mistake. Viewed over time, Liberman repeatedly chooses to rupture political partnerships rather than pursue practical solutions. And the principles he invokes to justify one rupture rarely seem to constrain him the next time around.Think that Liberman sounds like a right-winger? Not at all. Just an opportunist. Liberman has played fast and loose with the idea of Palestinian statehood, sometimes fiercely opposing it and at other times smarmily signaling his approval – depending on what served his political interests.As transportation minister in 2004, Liberman proposed a partition plan involving territorial exchanges between Israel and the Palestinians, under which the Arab Triangle, the Wadi Ara area, much of the Galilee, and most of eastern Jerusalem would be transferred to Arab sovereignty.As foreign minister in 2014, when he was seeking to ingratiate himself in Washington, he declared that he would be willing to evacuate his home in Nokdim (a Gush Etzion settlement) in exchange for peace.And just a few months ago, Liberman proposed handing over security control of Areas A and B in Judea and Samaria to the Jordanian army, Hashemite soldiers instead of Abbas’ henchmen.Liberman's record of incitement and vengeance Of course, Liberman did not ask the Jordanians about this nor consult the IDF. Both would have dismissed the proposal as sheer madness. Neither would have mistaken it for a serious right-wing policy initiative. Both would surely have recognized it as an attempt to grab headlines and score political points.It is also worth recalling Liberman’s many bombastic and aggressive outbursts on sensitive issues that demand statesmanship and nuance, two qualities he conspicuously lacks.Liberman the strongman called for the bombing of the Aswan Dam in response to Egypt’s support of Yasser Arafat. Liberman the autocrat wanted to transfer Arabs of the Galilean triangle to Palestinian control and to denaturalize all Arab citizens who failed a pledge of loyalty to the Jewish state. Liberman the executioner demanded the death penalty for Arab terrorists.Liberman the propagandist has spearheaded campaigns against religious influence – particularly the supposed threat of hadata (religionization) – for decades. In fact, Liberman’s religion-baiting political campaigns have gone way beyond the limits of acceptable debate about religion and politics, and his party’s campaign advertisements have been near antisemitic. Were such tactics employed abroad, every major Jewish advocacy organization would rightly raise an outcry.Overall, Liberman strikes me as a cross between American right-wing extremist Tucker Carlson – a populist provocateur and rabble-rouser – and Russian dictator Vladimir Putin, who excels at accumulating power and projecting influence despite his underlying weakness.Indeed, Liberman’s contribution to Israeli politics ranges from negligible to downright detrimental. He has no record to speak of, aside from incitement and vindictiveness. I cannot think of a single positive contribution to Israeli society, the economy, national defense, or foreign policy by Liberman or the Knesset faction members he has personally selected with an iron hand over the past 40 years (quite a few of whom have ended up in jail).Does anybody remember Liberman’s tenures as minister of infrastructure, transport, strategic affairs, finance, foreign affairs, and defense? Did any concrete achievement or worthwhile policy doctrine emerge from his years in these senior positions? Not at all.Now, of course, Liberman wants to co-opt, not crush, the haredi public with draft exemption chicanery.In February, he warned Rabbi Dov Lando (a spiritual leader of Degel Hatorah) that every one of his students would be forcibly dragged to the Bakum (the IDF induction center), “once and for all.” He insisted that haredim should be stripped of their right to vote unless they enlisted in the IDF.After the election, Liberman is suddenly championing exemptions from military service for haredi men. And liberal left-wing elites in academia, the media, and the legal establishment are eagerly embracing the idea – all for the “greater good” of ousting Netanyahu.According to some reports, the boondoggle would involve blanket, retroactive amnesty from the military draft for 90,000 yeshiva boys and kollel men. And this, in liaison with that same Dov Lando – a rabbi who recently mocked religious IDF soldiers as gratuitous baby killers.This is an outrage, but also a reversal entirely characteristic of Liberman. His modus operandi remains unchanged: manufacturing crises, undermining political partnerships, and promoting himself at every turn. As I said, it is enough to give you whiplash – and nausea.It is hard to tarnish the reputation of politicians any further than it already has been, but Liberman is doing an impressive job of it. The man who has turned political sabotage into an art form now wants us to entrust him with the leadership of the country. What a prospect.The writer is Managing Senior Fellow at the Jerusalem-based Misgav Institute for National Security & Zionist Strategy. The views expressed here are his own. His diplomatic, defense, political, and Jewish world columns over the past 30 years are at davidmweinberg.comFollow us on Google

Original Source

Read the full article at Jpost →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.