7 Best Witchy Books For Fall

Published Aug 23, 2026, 9:35 PM EDT Dani Kessel Odom (they/them) is an autistic lead writer and TV critic who covers sci-fi shows like Doctor Who and Pluribus, fantasy shows like The Magicians and Percy Jackson, and horror of all kinds. They also cover Marvel and DC TV shows and movies, with a robust knowledge of comic books. Their TV reviews can be found on Rotten Tomatoes. Dani is also part of ScreenRant's books team, using their fiction writing and literature studies as the backbone for their book analyses. They have covered events, such as the Denver Fan Expo. Professionals in the field, such as Damien Leone and Lucy Hale, have shared their articles. Their review of Ponies was quoted in the show's TV trailer. In university, they majored in English Writing with a minor in psychology. They have always had a passion for analyzing TV and movies, even taking filmography and scriptwriting classes in university. They also studied and participated in onstage and onscreen acting extensively from the ages of 7 to 18. Aside from working at Screen Rant, Dani has worked as a freelance editor and writer over the past decade, often in a ghostwriting capacity. Fall is right around the corner, and these seven witchy books will get you in the mood for the season of crisp weather and pumpkin patches. Summer is coming to an end, and soon we’ll move into autumn. Whether you plan on going to haunted houses or walking through a pumpkin patch, there’s so much to enjoy about the season. As the weather gets colder, you may find yourself seeking comfort under a nice blanket with a cozy TV show or a nice book. An ideal fantasy subgenre for fall is witchy books, especially those set in autumn. They suck you into a world unlike our own, plus they bring the magical spirit of Halloween to life. If you’re looking for a good mental escape, these seven witchy books will set the mood for fall and keep you going throughout the season. Some selections tell cozy fantasy romance stories that will make you swoon, while others lean into suspense and mystery. So settle in with a cup of tea or coffee and get to reading. 7 The Very Secret Society Of Irregular Witches by Sangu Mandanna The 2022 cozy fantasy romance book, The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches, follows Mika Moon, a young British witch who hides her magic except in social media videos. She expects nobody will believe it's real. However, she gets a mysterious request to help train three young witches. There, she finds herself surrounded by a group of quirky and dysfunctional individuals, including a prickly librarian at Nowhere House who intrigues Mika. Nowhere House is the perfectly enchanted world to escape into, and the characters are so completely lovable. The relationship between Mika and the young witches is reminiscent of Rory and Lorelai from Gilmore Girls. All in all, the book feels like a warm hug on a crisp autumn night, making it the perfect book to get you in the mood for fall. 6 The Lighthouse Witches by C. J. Cooke The Lighthouse Witches is for people who love everything that goes bump in the night. In the 17th century, witch trials are underway on the island of Lon Haven. In 1998, Liv moves her children to the island, where she is commissioned to paint a mural on a lighthouse built over a cave haunted by wildlings, supernatural beings that look like human children, as revenge for the witch trials. Liv and two of her daughters disappear. In the future, a pregnant Luna returns to the island when one of her sisters shows up, the same age as when she disappeared. These three timelines are woven together in a chilling mystery that will keep audiences guessing until the end. Cooke creates a spooky atmosphere without being overly terrifying, meaning folks who hate traditional horror can read it without concern. Plus, the book features elements of ancient folklore and gothic literature. 5 Deja Brew by Celeste Martin Deja Brew is the perfect witchy story to get in the autumn mood. In the book, Sirena Caraway is a kitchen witch whose powers are out of whack. She loses out on a job and embarrasses herself at a Halloween party. Before midnight, she makes a wish on her star for a second chance. This creates a time loop in which she repeats October. The only person who can help her is a witch named Gus Dearwood. They make a deal that she will help decipher a mysterious cookbook, and he’ll help her get her magical abilities back in line. The moderately spicy Black Love romance is a delightfully light and swoonworthy read. Because it takes place in the fall, we get all the pumpkin spice, boots, sweaters, and golden leaves that a reader could want. Sirena and Gus’ romance feels authentic, and it’s easy to root for them to not only fix their lives but get together. 4 The Lone Wolf Cafe by Sydney Wilder Sydney Wilder’s The Lone Wolf Cafe is a fun, Sapphic werewolf and witch romance set in a magical Maine small town full of witches in the days leading up to Halloween. A werewolf woman named Nettie Clarke flees her hometown without any money or idea where to go. She finds the town of Wisteria Grove and sneaks into a cafe. When the owner, Rowena Hawthorne, discovers her, she makes an offer. If Nettie works as the cafe’s baker and pretends to be a witch, she will pay her enough to survive in the town. Although she only plans to stay for a short time, Nettie finds herself connecting with her job, the elemental witches in the town, and Rowena. The relationship between Rowena and Nettie is really sweet, and the Halloween timeframe makes it a great read for fall. There’s enough drama and mystery to keep the story moving forward, but it remains low-stakes. 3 The Scapegracers by H.A. Clarke The main character Sideways Pike comes out as nonbinary in the second book, The Scratch Daughters, and switches to they/them pronouns. As such, I will be using they/them pronouns in this entry, even though the first book will use she/her pronouns. The book series The Scapegracers is a YA book that’s just as satisfying for adults, and it’s also a perfect witchy book for the spooky season. The book centers on a lesbian witch named Sideways Pike, who is a complete outcast. They are hired by three popular girls to cast a spell at their Halloween party, and the teen witch gets swept into the group. The four, now a powerful coven, decide to get revenge on the misogynistic dudebros from their high school. However, they also have to escape witch hunters. The Scapegracers is the first book in a really great trilogy that feels thrilling and magical. It’s hard to compare the book to a single story, but it feels like a little The Witches of Eastwick, a little Carrie, and a little Heathers. There's plenty of teen girl rage to go around. Plus, the story is queer-normative, with members of the coven being some form of LGBTQ+, plenty of trans and gender-expansive characters, and no traditional homophobic storylines. 2 The Book Witch by Meg Schaffer Meg Schaffer’s The Book Witch is one of the most whimsical and delightful books of the past year, and it’s a great option to get readers in the fall mood. The book centers on Rainy March, a book witch, bound by an oath to protect fictional stories from all foes. To preserve the stories, she cannot eat, drink, or sleep inside the books, let alone fall in love with a character. However, all of this is challenged when her grandfather disappears, and a priceless book is stolen. She needs help from the British detective Duke of Chicago, who stars in her favorite book series. Although it doesn’t take place in a specific season, The Book Witch feels like an autumn read. The writing creates a feeling of whimsy. The magical umbrellas, secret covens, and cat familiars all feel like they’re meant for the spooky season. The Book Witch has a cozy tone, which is ideal for the changing weather. Just grab a good mug of apple cider and a warm blanket. 1 Witchlore by Emma Hinds The dark academia romantasy book Witchlore is incredibly enjoyable and puts me in an autumn mood. Set at Demdike College of Witchcraft, the book follows Orlando, a nonbinary outcast shapeshifter who has no control over their magic or their body shifts between male and female bodies. They are grieving the loss of their girlfriend, Elizabeth, and they turn to the charming new student, Bastian, who is offering to cast a spell to raise her from the dead. However, Orlando begins to wonder who Bastian really is as they find themselves attracted to the mysterious young man. The romance between Orlando and Bastian is really heartwarming, and it’s nice to see a man-nonbinary romance, as most witchy books focus on women characters. The exploration of grief and mental health felt really thoughtful. On top of that, Witchlore has a refreshingly unique magic system and an extremely well-developed world. Between the magical world, coziness, and necromancy, it feels right at home in the spooky season.